|
|
| Line 107: |
Line 107: |
| | </td> | | </td> |
| | | | |
| - | <tr> <td colspan="3" height="15px"> </td></tr>
| |
| - | <tr><td bgColor="#e7e7e7" colspan="3" height="1px"> </tr>
| |
| - | <tr> <td colspan="3" height="5px"> </td></tr>
| |
| | | | |
| | + | <tr> <td colspan="3"> |
| | | | |
| | | | |
| - | <!--Project content -->
| |
| | | | |
| - | <tr><td>
| |
| - | <br>
| |
| - | <p><b><font size="5">Overall project summary</font></b></p><br>
| |
| | | | |
| - | There are currently over 260 million dairy cows worldwide, each producing 115 kg CO2 equivalent per day, or about 2.7% of global greenhouse gas emissions<sup>1,2,3</sup>. In South America, Africa and Asia, deforestation to make way for pastureland is an urgent concern. About 83% of the deforestation in the Amazon rainforest is used for pasture<sup>4</sup>.
| + | <p><b>Future Plans</b><br> |
| - | <br><br>
| + | The Real Vegan Cheese team has successfully crowd source fundraised $37K and is committed to continuing the project. For the iGEM competition we have successfully cloned into E. coli for both human and bovine casein proteins, sequenced to confirm cloning, and cloned into yeast.<br> |
| - | The Real Vegan Cheese Project intends to reduce dependence on large-scale commercial dairy in the production of cheese and casein-derived products by replacing the dairy cow with baker’s yeast, Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We are engineering the synthesis of bovine and human Alpha-S1, Alpha-S2, Beta and Kappa casein proteins as well as a kinase enzyme that may help the process of making a solid cheese. It is our hope that we can synthetically produce cheese that is more ethical, healthier and produces lower emissions than traditional dairy. | + | Future experiments include:<br> |
| - | <br><br> | + | <ul> |
| - | By replacing dairy cows with carbon-sequestering bioreactors, we could save thousands of doe-eyed Holsteins and Jerseys from the misfortunes of the industrial farm, reduce the incentive for deforestation and drastically lower the GHG emissions of casein and cheese production. We estimate that we could reduce emissions per gram of casein by 40-90%.
| + | <li>Expression and purification of all proteins |
| - | <br><br> | + | <li>Cheese formulation |
| - | Furthermore, Real Vegan Cheese is committed to open source and open patent biology. It is our hope that this process can be employed and improved upon by enterprising biologists, hackers and epicures the world over.
| + | <li>Cheese production |
| - | <br><br> | + | <li>Cloning into E. coli once we have the sequence for Narwhal genes, and work towards Narwhal cheese. |
| | + | </ul> |
| | | | |
| - | <p><b><font size="5">Project Details</font></b></p><br>
| |
| | | | |
| - | On paper, making <i>Real Vegan Cheese</i> should be simple. First, genetically engineer brewer’s yeast to produce cheese protein. Then, grow the yeast in a bioreactor and purify the protein. Combine the cheese proteins with a vegan milkfat replacement, a (nonlactose) sugar to feed the ripening bacteria, and water to produce a sort of vegan milk. From there, proceed with the age-old traditional cheesemaking process for the desired type of cheese.<br>
| |
| - | In practice, it gets a bit more complicated. Milk, it turns out, is a fairly complex substance. It is nature’s solution for packing large quantities of protein, calcium, and fat into liquid form that can turn into a solid for prolonged nutrient release in a suckling mammal’s stomach—a pretty impressive bit of biochemistry.<br><br>
| |
| - | <b>The Structure of Cheese</b><br>
| |
| - | Time for some dairy science: given the right pH and calcium concentration, four of the more hydrophobic milk proteins assemble into micellar aggregates that include calcium ions and milkfat molecules. One of these caseins, kappa-casein, acts as a sort of built-in surfactant by making up the surface of the micelle and extending its hydrophilic tail into the watery solution. Making hard and semi-hard cheese usually involves the use of the rennet enzyme Chymosin, which cuts kappa-casein’s hydrophilic tail, making the now hydrophobic micelles link together into a network, forming cheese curd. This process is so efficient that it takes as little as 40 minutes to convert milk into something akin to a block of soft tofu floating in a watery solution.<br>
| |
| - | It’s not surprising that vegan cheese is hard to make. The cheesemaking process relies on specific protein interactions that simply do not occur with proteins from any nonmammalian source.<br>
| |
| - | The obvious solution is to invent a nonmammalian source of the required proteins.<br><br>
| |
| | | | |
| | + | We have many questions to answer including:<br> |
| | | | |
| - | <p><b><font size="5">Post-translational Modifications Required for Casein Micelle Formation</font></b></p><br><br> | + | <ul> |
| - | The path from initial protein expression to micelle formation is complex. The difficult part, it seems, is getting the purified protein to form correctly into micelles in imitation of the structure in milk. Getting transgenic proteins to fold correctly is often a problematic endeavor, usually involving considerations of protein secondary structure, tertiary structure, and post-translational modifications such as phosphorylation and glycosylation. So far, our research indicates that folding of individual proteins will not be an issue. [ref] <br><br>
| + | <li>How much cheese protein will we be able to make per liter? |
| | + | <li>How much will it cost? |
| | + | <li>Can we estimate the final production cost of the vegan cheese? |
| | + | <li>How does it compare to existing vegan cheese and normal cheese products? |
| | + | <li>Find cost of bulk milk for cheesemaking. What do current cheesemakers pay? |
| | + | <li>Find cost of running bioreactors |
| | + | <li>Figure out retail vs. production cost cheese markups |
| | + | <li>Check if alibaba bulk ingredient prices are realistic |
| | + | <li>Find cost of cheesemaking |
| | + | </ul> |
| | | | |
| - | With regard to glycosylation, its influence on micelle formation remains an open question. But even a glancing review of dairy science literature will show that correct phosphorylation is likely to make or break the project. [refs] Interestingly, though protein phosphorylation was originally discovered in casein and discovered way back in 1883 [2], the kinase enzyme responsible for this phosphorylation wasn’t identified until 2012 [3]. In mammals, this unusual kinase—no, not "casein kinase," but one named Fam20C—is actually secreted along with the cheese proteins, and our team is designing for a similar effect in yeast. By altering the kinase secretion sequence, optimizing the kinase sequence for yeast, and co-expressing it with cheese protein, we’re aiming for casein proteins correctly phosphorylated upon secretion.<br><br>
| |
| - |
| |
| - | <p><b><font size="5">The Molecular Biology of Making <i>Real Vegan Cheese</i></font></b></p><br><br>
| |
| - | The molecular part of our project breaks down into four discrete milestones. Full details about materials, methods, specific experiments and our results can be found in [link to iGEM wiki notebook]<br><br>
| |
| - | <b>Milestone 1: Part design. </b><br><br>
| |
| - | The milk proteins important for cheese are the four caseins: kappa, beta, alpha-s1, and alpha-s2 [ref]. For full details about these and our chosen casein variants, see [https://wiki.realvegancheese.org/index.php/Molecular_biology.] <br><br>
| |
| - | We start with published sequences for both the cow proteins and proteins from human milk, as bovine caseins are common human allergens. For the protein kinase, we use sequence from human Fam20C. No animals needed! <br><br>
| |
| - | First, the DNA sequences that code for milk proteins in mammals are codon-optimized for expression in yeast. Why? Each codon has multiple possible tRNAs that recognize that codon, and the abundance of tRNAs differs between species.
| |
| - | So these proteins will be secreted out of yeast cells, we then add DNA sequence coding for a native yeast secretion signal (alpha-factor) preceding each optimized casein DNA sequence. The addition of the alpha-factor signal peptide is commonly used for successful extra-cellular secretion of transgenic proteins in yeast, including casein derivatives. [refs]<br><br>
| |
| - | To complicate things, the small size and limited secondary and tertiary structure in our target proteins may make them more prone to unwanted degradation by proteases in the yeast secretory pathway. [ref], However, even if we use protease deficient yeast strains, the presence of the Kex2 protease is required to cleave the alpha-factor signal peptide from each of our proteins of interest and must remain in our expression system. Kex2 protease amino acid recognition sites (Lysine/Arginine and Arginine/Arginine) occur in the native sequence of three of our study proteins: bovine alpha casein S2, human kappa casein and FAM20C. For these, we will create two constructs: one which translates into the native amino acid sequence and one in which all Kex2 recognition sequences are disrupted to express biochemically similar amino acids (Lysine/Lysine). In the case that we obtain whole proteins from both constructs, we will continue with that containing native amino acid sequence.<br><br>
| |
| - | Finally, we add flanking regions that include recognition sequences for the SapI restriction enzyme, needed for the downstream cloning process, and BioBrick enzyme recognition sites. We also disrupt internal recognition sites for these restriction enzymes with synonymous DNA sequence mutations.<br><br>
| |
| - | We followed this process to create 11 constructs:<br><ul>
| |
| - | <li>Bovine alpha casein S1
| |
| - | <li>Bovine alpha casein S2 (Kex + & Kex -)
| |
| - | <li>Bovine beta casein B
| |
| - | <li>Bovine kappa casein
| |
| - | <li>Human alpha casein S1
| |
| - | <li>Human beta casein
| |
| - | <li>Human kappa casein (Kex + & Kex -)
| |
| - | <li>Human Fam20C kinase (Kex + & Kex -)
| |
| - | </ul>
| |
| - | [embed a representative figure.]
| |
| | <br> | | <br> |
| - | Construct details on Parts page.<br>
| + | As part of the future planning we incorporated as a California State Nonprofit Public Benefit Corporation under the official name Real Vegan Cheese on August 4th, 2014 with a purpose to promote, encourage, facilitate and engage in free and open scientific research and education. |
| - | <br><b>Milestone 2: Clone, transform plasmids to <i>E. coli,</i> & sequence confirm.</b><br><br>
| + | |
| | | | |
| - | We clone the composite DNA constructs into the pD1214 plasmid backbone using a kit that simultaneously digests at the external SapI sites and ligates. This plasmid can be selected in <i>E. coli</i> using its Ampicillin-resistance gene. It also contains a strong constitutive TEF promoter for gene expression in yeast and a URA3 marker for in Ura deficient yeast strains.
| |
| - | [uploaded a pD1214 figure. Need to embed; didn’t figure out how.]
| |
| - | <br><br>
| |
| - | The plasmids DNA are then transformed into <i> E. coli </i> for selection, the plasmid DNA is extracted, and submitted for DNA sequence confirmation. <br><br>
| |
| - | <b>Milestone 3: Transform plasmids to yeast.</b><br><br>
| |
| - | We are working with this strain of baker’s yeast: Saccharomyces cerevisiae, UV-Sensitive Strain, G948-1C/U, alpha, rad1 rad18 phr1 ura3 mutant in excision repair. It is Ura deficient, allowing for selection of our desired plasmid transformants on URA negative media.<br><br>
| |
| - | Why are we using <i>S. cerevisiae</i> yeast for casein protein expression?<br><br>
| |
| - | Advantages: <br><ul>
| |
| - | <li>A model system for trans-specific protein expression.
| |
| - | <li>Baker’s yeast is familiar as a human consumable.
| |
| - | <li>FDA GRAS status
| |
| - | <li>Easier to obtain a food-safe product
| |
| | | | |
| - | <br><br>Potential problems<br><br>
| |
| - | "Although S. cerevisiae has a well-developed eukaryotic secretory pathway, it is not the most efficient yeast for high-level export of proteins to the extracellular medium." "...often transport to the extracellular medium is inefficient, especially for complex mammalian proteins of high molecular weight." -- Overview of Protein Expression in Saccharomyces cerevisiae by Strausberg and Strausberg. [ref].
| |
| - | <br><br>
| |
| - | If protein cleavage in the secretory pathway is a problem, we will need to obtain a protease deficient yeast strain that still contains Kex2.<br><br>
| |
| - | <b>Milestone 4: Verify protein expression and secretion in yeast and purify proteins from yeast growth medium</b><br><br>
| |
| - | So far this is all standard genetic engineering, and while getting the yeast to express and secrete enough protein may prove challenging, this part of the project should not present any extraordinary problems—in fact, we’ve already discovered published papers demonstrating that most of the casein proteins can be expressed in yeast or <i>E. coli </i>. [refs] We will verify protein expression in yeast culture supernatants via SDS PAGE gel electrophoresis, then explore protein purification methods.<br><br>
| |
| - |
| |
| - | Summary of current results:<br><br><ul>
| |
| - | <li><b>Milestone 1): Part design </b> Done!
| |
| - | <li><b>Milestone 2): Clone, transform plasmids to <i>E. coli,</i> & sequence confirm.</b> 10 done; have not yet gotten a successful transformation of human kappa casein (Kex -) into <i>E. coli.</i>.
| |
| - | <li><b>Milestone 3): Transform plasmids to yeast. </b> Not complete. Currently optimizing our yeast expression system.
| |
| - | <li><b>Milestone 4): Verify protein expression and secretion in yeast and purify proteins from yeast growth medium. </b> Not yet attempted.<br><br></ul>
| |
| - | But we’re not stopping here! Head over the Real Vegan Cheese wiki [link] to keep following our progress.
| |
| - |
| |
| - | <p><b><font size="5">Conclusions</font></b></p><br>
| |
| - |
| |
| - | We have gone through numerous hurdles; we have strived and put our utmost effort into keeping this project open source and non-profit.
| |
| - | We represent something different - something revolutionary. Powered by citizen science and representing a community spirit, we are attempting to do something that will provide vegans, lactose intolerant people, and people with cow’s milk allergies around the world with an alternative- real vegan cheese.
| |
| - | We are attempting to make a real vegan cheese by engineering normal baker's yeast (S. cerevisiae) to express milk proteins (caseins), purifying the proteins, creating a milk-substitute by blending in vegan replacements for lactose and milk fat, and finally turning the resulting milk-substitute into semi-hard cheese like gouda using the regular cheese-making process.
| |
| - | In doing so we are not only creating something that will revolutionize the food industry, but we are also representing the groundbreaking concept of citizen science and community labs. We are giving people of all sorts of ages and experience the opportunity to learn and take part in something revolutionary.
| |
| - |
| |
| - | <p><b>Citations</b></p><ol><i>
| |
| - | <li>http://www.progressivedairy.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=6491:how-much-gas-do-cows-produce
| |
| - | <li>http://www.dairyco.org.uk/market-information/farming-data/cow-numbers/world-cow-numbers/#.VD32QCT4sns
| |
| - | <li>http://www.fao.org/news/story/en/item/41348/icode/
| |
| - | <li>http://www.cifor.org/publications/pdf_files/media/Amazon.pdf
| |
| - | </ol></i>
| |
| | </td></tr> | | </td></tr> |
| - |
| |
| | | | |
| | </table> | | </table> |
"
