Team:Cooper Union/TdT project

De novo Enzyme Mediated Oligonucleotide Synthesizer

De novo synthesis is a way of creating DNA oligonucleotides without the need of a template strand. Since the conventional method is expensive, time consuming, and inefficient, our team wants to focus on the ways to minimize the time and money required for DNA synthesis and to allow the labs to produce oligonucleotides easily without ordering. Here we introduce the De novo Enzyme Mediated Oligonucleotide Synthesizer (DEMOS); a programmable enzyme based, template-free, synthesizer for nucleic acid polymers. Our eventual goal will be to build a microfluidic de novo synthesizer that will allow laboratories, from academia to DIYBio community labs to rapidly and economically synthesize any strand of DNA for their projects.We hope that this system will become the key platform that bridges the in silico to in vitro gap in the design-test-build cycle of DNA synthesis and experimentation.

Our system is fundamentally based on two key technologies, one practical and the other theoretical: 1) the development of deoxynucleotide triphosphate (dNTP) substrates with 3' reversible protective groups for "sequencing by synthesis" and "hot start" PCR technologies and the published theoretical model of directed template-free synthesis of DNA using the enzyme terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase. This enzyme that has the ability to add nucleotides to the 3' ends of DNA, preferable 3' overhangs, in a template-free manner. (TdT).

In the general scheme shown in Figure 1 below, a growing DNA chain possessing a free 3'OH end has one incoming 3'-RPdNTP (reverse protective group dNTP) enzymatically added by TdT at the permissive temperature of 37 degrees Celsius. This is followed by a wash step to remove unincorporated 3'RPdNTPs and PPi (pyrophosphate). Deprotection is achieved by raising the temperature to 95 degrees Celsius, in the case of heat labile protective groups, or pulsing with ultra-violet light when using photolabile protective groups. This is followed by another wash that removes decoupled protective groups, thereby resetting the system to begin another cycle of addition.



Figure 2 below summarizes the reaction and structure of two heat labile 3'protective group dNTPs that are commercially available from TriLink Biotechnologies (www.trilinkbiotech.com). For our proof of concept experiments, 3'-TBE-dNTP was used, as it has a faster rate of deprotection at 95 degrees Celsius; 3'-TBE-dNTP t 1/2 + 5 minutes, 3'-THF-dNTP t 1/2= 90 minutes)



Advantages of Our System vs. Phosphoramidite Mediated Oligonucleotide Synthesis

Advantages of Our System vs. pH Regulated De novo Enzyme Mediated DNA Synthesis

In the controllable system proposed by Ud-Dean, the reversibility of a 3' acetyl protective group was achieved by lowering pH during each cycle and thereby activating a deacetylase enzyme that is active at lower pH. During this step, TdT is also inactived by the shift to lower pH, thereby preventing the addition of extra nucleotides

Our system simplifies this novel approach by thermolabile reversible 3' protective groups, thereby combining the

Future Improvements to the De novo Oligonucleotide Synthesizer

In our present configuration, full length recombinant bovine TdT was used in the reaction. This particular enzyme denatures in the presence of elevated temperatures, thereby necessitating the repeated addition of enzyme during each step of nucleotide addition after blocking group removal via 95 degrees C heat pulse. Therefore it would be useful to either isolate a naturally occurring variant of TdT or similar enzyme, that is heat tolerant, most likely from a thermophylic organism, or engineer such a variant. Another potential course of improvement would be to construct truncated and other variants of engineered TdT that exhibit faster kinetics of modified nucleotide incorporation. Lastly, our present system used commercially available nucleotides that had heat labile 3' protective groups. By switching to photolabile nucleotides, the system should perform better by exhibiting an overall faster reaction cycle, since temperature ramp up and down cycles are avoided and no extra TdT enzyme would need to be added at the beginning of each cycle, as heat denaturation would also be avoided. We are presently exploring these improved features.

Potential Errors in the Synthesis System

During each cycle there are independent sources of error that can affect the overall efficiency of the reaction. The most obvious errors include: 1) Incomplete enzymatic addition of 3' reversibly protected dNTPs by TdT during the nucleotide incorporation step. 2) Incomplete hydrolysis of 3' protective group during heating or other treatment. 3) Incomplete removal of unincorporated 3' reversibly protected nucleotides after each incorporation step. 4) Spontaneous hydrolysis of 3' protective groups prior to intended deprotection. Each error, if not sufficiently addressed would compound the likelihood of misincorporated nucleotides and a reduction of overall yield.

For example, during error scenario 1, oligonucletide chains that have not had a 3' reversibly protective group nucleotide added during an incorporation step, will, during the subsequent step after deprotection, be potential substrates for the addition of the next incoming nucleotide. This would lead to the base deletion. During error scenario 2, the failure to remove a protective group would lead to a population of oligonucleotides that would fail to add a nucleotide during the next subsequent addition of incoming nucleotides, leading to a base deletion at this step. For error scenario 3, the presence of unremoved, unreacted nucletides would lead to misincorporation and hence base substitutions during each subsequent stage of oligonucleotide elongation. During Scenario 4, the presence of dNTPs without 3' protective groups would lead to the incorporation of multiple dNTPs, resulting in homopolymeric stretches of nucleotides in the growing oligonucleotide chain. This would lead to insertion mutations. For a truly reliable system to be built, these and potentially other sources of error will need to be adequately countered.

References

1.Minhaz Ud-Dean, S.M. (2008) A Theoretical Model for Template-Free Synthesis of Long DNA Sequence. Syst. Synth. Biol. 2:67-73
2.Koukhareva, I. and Lebedev, A. (2009) 3'-Protected 2'-Deoxynucleoside 5'-Triphosphates as a Novel Tool for Heat-Triggered Activation of PCR. Anal Chem. 81(12):4955-4962
3.Kuan, W.L., Joy, J. Mee, N.F., Perlyn, K.Z., Wen, T.S., Nguen, T., James, J., Chai, E., Flotow, H., Crasta, S., Chua, K., Peng, N.S. and Hill, J. (2010) Generation of Active Bovine Terminal Deoxynucleotidyl Transferase (TdT) in E. coli. Biochemistry Insights. 3: 41-46.
4.Boule, J.B., Rougeon, F.Papanicolaou, C. (2001) Terminal Deoxynucleotidyl Transferase Indiscriminately Incorporates Ribonucleotides and Deoxyribonucleotides. J. Biol. Chem. 276, 33: 31388-31393.
5.Motea, E.A. and Berdis, A.J. (2010) Terminal Deoxynucleotidyl Transferase: The Story of a Misguided DNA Polymerase. Biochim. Biophys. Acta. 1804, 5: 1151-1166.
6.Gardner, A.F., Wang, J., Wu, W., Karouby, J., Li, H., Stupi, B.P., Jack, W.E., Hersh, M.N. and Metzker, M.L. (2012) Rapid Incorporation Kinetics and Improved Fidelity of a Novel Class of 3'-OH Unblocked Reversible Terminators. Nucleic Acids Research. 40, 15: 7404-7415.