Team:Toulouse/ethics

From 2014.igem.org

(Difference between revisions)
 
(51 intermediate revisions not shown)
Line 10: Line 10:
   <link href='http://fonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Open+Sans:800' rel='stylesheet' type='text/css'>
   <link href='http://fonts.googleapis.com/css?family=Open+Sans:800' rel='stylesheet' type='text/css'>
 +
 +
<script type='text/javascript' src='http://ajax.googleapis.com/ajax/libs/jquery/1.9.0/jquery.min.js'></script>
 +
 +
<script type='text/javascript'> $(function(){
 +
  $(window).scroll(function () {
 +
    if ($(this).scrollTop() > 250) {
 +
        $('#column-left').addClass("fixNavigation");
 +
    } else {
 +
        $('#column-left').removeClass("fixNavigation");
 +
        }
 +
    });
 +
  });
 +
</script>
  <!--/* CSS contenu*/-->
  <!--/* CSS contenu*/-->
Line 15: Line 28:
  <style type="text/css">
  <style type="text/css">
-
   .title1{color:#20a8da; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-weight:600; font-size:24px;  margin:0 0 33px 0; border:none;}
+
   .title1{color:green; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-weight:600; font-size:24px;  margin:0 0 33px 0; border:none;}
   .title2{color:#5a6060; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-weight:600; font-size:18px; margin:0 0 30px 0; border:none;}
   .title2{color:#5a6060; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-weight:600; font-size:18px; margin:0 0 30px 0; border:none;}
   .title3{color:#7f8c8c; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-weight:400; font-size:16px; margin:0 0 20px 0; border:none;}
   .title3{color:#7f8c8c; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-weight:400; font-size:16px; margin:0 0 20px 0; border:none;}
 +
 
 +
  .title4{color:#5a6060; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-weight:700; font-size:15px; margin:0 0 20px 0; border:none;}
 +
 
 +
  .texte{color:#5a6060; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-size:14px; margin:0 0 50px 0; line-height:24px; text-align:justify;}
 +
 +
  .citation{color:#5a6060; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-size:18px; margin:0 0 50px 0; line-height:24px; font-style: italic; text-align: center;}
-
  .texte{color:#5a6060; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-size:14px; margin:0 0 50px 0; line-height:24px; }
+
p.legend{color:#5a6060; font-family:'Open Sans'; font-size:14px; margin:0 0 50px 0; line-height:24px; text-align: center;}
.banniere{
.banniere{
Line 92: Line 111:
     display :block;
     display :block;
 +
}
 +
 +
table {
 +
display: table;
 +
border-collapse: separate;
 +
border-spacing: 2px;
 +
border-color: gray;
 +
}
 +
 +
table[Attributes Style] {
 +
border-top-width: 1px;
 +
border-right-width: 1px;
 +
border-bottom-width: 1px;
 +
border-left-width: 1px;
 +
width: 100%;
 +
height: 20%;
 +
}
 +
 +
#column-left{
 +
float:left;
 +
width: 190px;
 +
float: left;
 +
padding: 15px 10px 15px 15px;
 +
border: 1px solid #ccc;
 +
border-radius: 5px;
 +
background-color: #eee;
 +
}
 +
 +
.fixNavigation{
 +
z-index: 9999;
 +
position: fixed;
 +
top:15px;
 +
width:240px;
 +
}
 +
 +
ul.menuleft {
 +
padding-left:10px;
 +
}
 +
 +
 +
ul.menuleft li {
 +
padding-bottom: 10px;
 +
}
 +
 +
ul.menuleft li a{
 +
color:#5a6060;
 +
font-family:'Open Sans';
 +
font-size:14px;
 +
margin:0 0 0 0;
 +
line-height:24px;
}
}
      
      
Line 100: Line 169:
   <div style="margin:0 auto; width:960px;">
   <div style="margin:0 auto; width:960px;">
   <p style="color:#696969; padding-top:20px; font-size:16px; float:left;"> Human practice&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ethics</p>  
   <p style="color:#696969; padding-top:20px; font-size:16px; float:left;"> Human practice&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;>&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;Ethics</p>  
-
    <ul class="topnav" id="topnav" style="top:15px;">
 
-
                <li style="padding-right:0px"><a href="http://2014.igem.org/Team:Toulouse/Team" class="navlink" style="color:#696969; font-weight:normal">Acknowlegdement<i style="padding-left: 10px;font-size: 14px;font-family: verdana;">></i> </a>
 
-
                    <ul class="subnav" style="background:none;">
 
-
                        <li class="libasedrop"><a class="basedrop" href="http://2014.igem.org/Team:Toulouse/acknowlegdement/attribution">Attribution</a></li>
 
-
                        <li class="libasedrop"><a class="basedrop" href="http://2014.igem.org/Team:Toulouse/acknowlegdement/sponsor">Sponsor</a></li>
 
-
                  </ul>
 
-
                </li>
 
-
        </ul>
 
   </div>  
   </div>  
   </div>
   </div>
-
 
 
-
  <div id="innercontenthome">
+
<div id="innercontenthome">
       <div class="centering" style="padding-top: 85px; padding-bottom:40px;">
       <div class="centering" style="padding-top: 85px; padding-bottom:40px;">
-
       <p class="texte">Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Phasellus turpis urna, dapibus auctor mi eu, mollis ultrices nisl. Nunc suscipit tortor mi. In sapien nunc, condimentum in commodo quis, lobortis et arcu. Proin accumsan nunc eget ante luctus ornare. Nunc laoreet elit vel vulputate fermentum. Integer faucibus, nunc non lobortis faucibus, ante mauris posuere ligula, sed laoreet lectus turpis a nisl. Morbi ac enim felis.</p>
+
<div id="column-left">
 +
<h3 class="title2" style="margin-top:10px; color:#333;">Summary :</h3>
 +
<ul class="menuleft">
 +
  <li style="margin-top:25px;"><a href="#select1">Protection of the beauty</a></li>
 +
  <li><a href="#select2">Human intervention in the nature</a></li>
 +
  <li><a href="#select3">SubtiTree</a></li>
 +
</ul>
 +
</div>
 +
 
 +
<div class="column-right" style="width:75%; float:right;">
 +
 
 +
<!--CITATION-->
 +
<p class="citation">
 +
"Knowledge without conscience is but the ruin of the soul."</br>
 +
"Science sans conscience, n'est que ruine de l'âme", François Rabelais, 16<sup>th</sup> century.
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
       <p class="texte">The ethical
 +
questioning turned out to be one of the major starting points of our project.
 +
Acting on an established environment and modifying it is by no mean trivial and
 +
our combined technical and philosophical points of view. The actual purpose of our project also leads us to undertake an
 +
ethical questioning about the role of the scientist regarding “useless” things
 +
such as the trees lining along the Canal du Midi. </p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="title1" id="select1">Protection of the beauty</p>
 +
<p class="title2">Is it the scientists’ role to protect beauty?
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte"> Beauty is a
 +
feeling of satisfaction and is selfless. It is more a feeling than the property
 +
of a thing, this is not a notion we can clearly understand. Indeed, we can find
 +
something beautiful even when we don’t know the purpose of the object...</p>
 +
<center>
 +
<img src="http://2014.igem.org/wiki/images/f/fa/Fontaine_Duchamp.jpg" width="400px">
 +
<p class="legend">Figure 1: Fontaine (Marcel Duchamp). Yes this is also art...</p></center>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">There is always
 +
a distinction between natural beauty and artistic beauty according to Hegel,
 +
a German philosopher. The artistic beauty is born from our mind and our
 +
spirit: it is an element of signification of the work of art whereas the
 +
natural beauty of the object is external. In a way, the Canal du Midi combines
 +
both types of beauty: a natural one regarding the Nature, the centenary plane
 +
trees but also an artistic one since the Canal was built by the human hands.
 +
Usually, science judges beauty as a superficial feature not deserving to
 +
undertake any kind of scientific efforts to maintain it. The traditional role
 +
of science is to solve global issues and to elaborate complex strategies in
 +
order to find useful solutions for everyone’s life. Once made this observation,
 +
one may wonder why synthetic biology would be used only to protect the useless
 +
beauty of a local heritage such as the trees lining the Canal du Midi.  
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">
 +
This crucial
 +
interrogation leads us to consider science and synthetic biology from a
 +
different point of view. <b>What if the role of scientists was also to make
 +
people rediscovering the beauty of Nature? What if the bases of new scientific
 +
challenges resulted from a more local scale? </b>Science does not have to be it has so much to gain opening itself to these
 +
challenges. First scientifically, as research is never
 +
useless and as we never know the impact and the scope of our results.
 +
Then socially, as we could measure the deep interest raised by our
 +
project within the population and the media. Adopting a new vision of synthetic
 +
biology, we will probably make people change their mind about this innovative
 +
discipline. <br>
 +
The traditional cold objectivity of science distances itself from the society.
 +
However, scientists are also being capable of feeling the beauty, sensitive to
 +
the charm of landscapes and <b>able to understand the usefulness of
 +
"useless" trees</b>…<br>
 +
The design of a strategy to protect useless beauty may seem senseless but we
 +
believe that it is also the scientist’s duty. We have to remember that thinking
 +
is what distinguish <i>Homo sapiens</i> from other species on earth and this
 +
"thinking" feature allows us to understand the world and be conscious
 +
of our human Nature (Descartes: <i>Cogito ergo sum</i>). The art is an object
 +
of philosophical thought. Consciousness raises humans above all others living
 +
creatures. Thus, it is necessary to respect and protect art. And thus, it
 +
becomes essential to preserve the beauty of the Canal du Midi.
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<p class="title1" id="select2">Human intervention on  Nature</p>
 +
<p class="texte">Our main question is to understand the complicated relationship between man and Nature.
 +
Does mankind have the proper right to change the Nature? Is modified Nature considered as artificial?</p>
 +
<p class="title2"> Mankind & Nature</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte"> Nature deserves
 +
to be respected and loved. Mankind has always been linked to Nature as its
 +
survival depends on what comes out of the ground, the trees, the oceans… The
 +
Nature is a source of wealth for mankind. It ensures survival and development
 +
by giving men the wood, the rocks, the soil to build shelters. Being in contact
 +
with Nature can allow men to feel strong emotion, as describe by poets like
 +
Hugo and Lamartine.</p>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">Since the birth
 +
of humanity, man himself understood the importance of studying and mastering
 +
Nature to develop the civilization. Still today the most advanced technologies
 +
often try to mimic natural phenomena. With the development of civilization, men
 +
modified their environment, changing it for their own comfort depending on
 +
their own desire. With the increase of human activity, the natural environment
 +
is modified profundly. With industrialization, the
 +
natural environment suffered from waste discharges, oil slicks, intensive
 +
fishing (and many others...) but also the introduction of devastating species
 +
such as the pathogen,<i> Ceratocystis
 +
platani</i>. However, despite these negative aspects, men
 +
are capable of favorable actions to help the environment and fix their
 +
mistakes. The current trend is to limit the impact of human interventions on
 +
Nature, and hopefully this trend is not transient and will not vanish. A new
 +
desire is born, a wish to protect Nature and wilderness. Humanity can adhere to
 +
this position: human take advantage of the
 +
environment and the environment takes advantage of the reasoned human
 +
interventions. There is an adaptation of mankind to Nature. Moreover, humans
 +
can have empathy: people are capable of understanding emotions and cognitive
 +
states of other organisms. To respond to these feelings, humans have
 +
technological tools allowing them to fight against enemies. This is the case
 +
with our project: fighting <i>Ceratocystis
 +
platani</i>.
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">In conclusion,
 +
by destroying and hammering the Nature, we jeopardize our lives. We need
 +
Nature, we come from Nature and we depend on Nature for survival, food,
 +
discoveries and civilisation. Respecting, loving and
 +
preserving the beauty of it is also a question of
 +
survival.</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="title2">Nature and artifice
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">Talking about
 +
the Nature refers to the whole world with an exception: all the transformations
 +
made by mankind. Nature exists regardless of men and his interventions whereas
 +
artificial is everything that exists because to humans.
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">However,
 +
pretending that natural and artificial are opposite does not seem to be true.
 +
Man cannot create without the various elements provided by Nature, he then justs transform Nature. Thus we may wonder if there is a
 +
true difference between natural and artificial. The border between these two
 +
notions is not as obvious as it seems. The landscapes are shaped by the hand of
 +
man, animals are domesticated, and now bacteria are considered as cell
 +
factories. A natural reserve is artificially preserved as a result of human
 +
actions. Is there still something natural since the birth of mankind? Actually,
 +
the artifice is a slight modification of Nature and couldn’t exist by itself.
 +
The distinction between natural and artificial seems sterile and we clearly
 +
understand that these notions are inextricably linked and need each other to
 +
exist. </p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">In conclusion,
 +
isn't it our duty to use our unique position in the history of life and our human
 +
approach to try to replace the evolutive processes?</p>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<p class="title2">Back to our project</p>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">These
 +
inextricable links are obviously the basis of our project. We aim to
 +
artificially preserve a natural heritage shaped by Pierre Paul Riquet hundreds years ago. Fighting a
 +
naturally occurring form of life that threatens it maybe just an imitation of
 +
the natural evolution process. What is considered today as ‘non-natural’
 +
may be one day regarded differently. To the extent that everything is done not
 +
to unbalance the ecosystem, our intervention can be judged rightful, even more
 +
than the use of chemicals.</p>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<p class="title1" id="select3">SubtiTree</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="title2"> Potential strategies discussed
 +
<br> (See more details in the <a href="http://2014.igem.org/Team:Toulouse/Project/Spreading">Spreading</a> dedicated page)
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">To be sure that
 +
SubtiTree will not survive and spread in the
 +
environment, many strategies were discussed to improve our bacterium:
 +
 
 +
<br>- Avoid the survival in the natural environment (outside the tree) thanks to a proline auxotrophy system
 +
<br>- Prevent the sporulation of <i>Bacillus subtilis</i> to make it annual 
 +
<br>- Avoid gene transfers between SubtiTree and a wild
 +
type bacterium thanks to a toxin-antitoxin system
 +
<br>- Use an integrative plasmid to improve the genetic stability
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<p class="title2">Public perception
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="title3">Political and public adhesion</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">Due to our
 +
strong implication in preserving this magnificent work of art, our project
 +
interested several governmental services. Indeed some municipalities and
 +
regional councils supported our local engagement. Beyond that, our project
 +
interests the highest level of the “Canal du Midi” administration: the national
 +
navigation authority (VNF) and the Ministry of agriculture. Both of them funded
 +
this project. They are now looking for the continuation of the project after
 +
the iGEM competition. This is clearly a sign that we targeted the right
 +
question. </p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">This project
 +
also received the attention of the public through several articles in
 +
newspapers, television, radio and internet. First we had just a local coverage,
 +
but days after days there were more and more media interested in SubtiTree. This mediatic coverage
 +
allowed us to contact concerned citizens who participated to the development of
 +
this project. This interaction with the public allowed us to explain and
 +
promote public knowledge of synthetic biology. </p>
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<p class="title3">Safety principle</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">One single tree
 +
infected by Canker, and all the trees located in an area of a couple of hundred
 +
meters around are included in the prophylactic cut. We acted to preserve the
 +
surrounding trees. The modification of the endophytic
 +
microbial fauna generated by the introduction of the engineered bacterium has
 +
to be compared to the introduction of chemicals. They contain chlorine atom and
 +
aromatic hydrocarbon, so their remediation is complicated and they represent a
 +
source of pollution. By shortening the lifespan to one season and minimizing
 +
the risks of spreading, we plan a safe and environmental-friendly way to fight
 +
Canker. 
 +
 
 +
 
 +
<p class="title2">Feasability
 +
</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">We wonder about
 +
the feasibility of tree’s treatment. As we used endophytic
 +
bacteria, we can count on the natural growth of SubtiTree
 +
inside the sap. So we can inject few bacteria to be sure to have enough
 +
bacteria to protect the tree. Some researchers (Xianling
 +
Ji<sup>1</sup> et al) already injected <i>B. subtilis</i> in plants and
 +
observed an increase of bacteria concentration to a maximum of 10<sup>5</sup>
 +
bacteria/mL</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">As we aim to
 +
inject a small quantity of bacteria, this treatment remains cheaper than the
 +
injection of several liters of chemical fungicides. In addition, this injection
 +
prevents the preventive tree cutting, which is very expensive. Cutting one tree
 +
cost around € 3000. The administration in charge of the protection of the
 +
“Canal du Midi” already plans to spend 220 million euros to cut and replant all
 +
trees along the Canal. Besides the important cost of cutting trees, it will
 +
destroy one of the symbols of south-western France. </p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="texte">We know that SubtiTree could be improved in many ways, but in the
 +
iGEM’s circumstances we could not have the time to go
 +
deeper. First, we can improve the fixation module. Using chitin as fixation
 +
anchor is simple but not enough specific to fix just one fungus type. That’s
 +
why we first think to fix SubtiTree to one protein
 +
included in the <i>Ceratocystis
 +
platani</i>’s
 +
membrane: CP. The bacterial prototype designed this summer can be optimized to
 +
trigger the fungicides production when the binding is completed, and to be more
 +
specific changing the peptides produced.</p>
 +
 
 +
<p class="title1">References</p>
-
<p class="texte">Vivamus varius aliquet nisl vel efficitur. Praesent congue mi vel elit volutpat posuere. Mauris vitae viverra urna. Cras ligula purus, malesuada ac molestie id, vestibulum eget magna. Quisque consequat erat vitae odio feugiat feugiat. Donec eleifend congue suscipit. Nam maximus nec elit vitae dapibus. Cras et rhoncus purus, quis scelerisque nunc. Integer mollis ut dolor at tincidunt. Cras feugiat, tellus id condimentum commodo, tortor urna lacinia sapien, eu convallis lorem ante id augue. Nullam vitae metus mi.</p>
+
<li class="tree"><p class="texte"> Xianling Ji, Guobing Lu, Yingping Gai, Chengchao Zheng,and Zhimei Mu.<b> Biological control against bacterialwilt and colonization of
 +
mulberry byan endophytic <i>Bacillus subtilis</i> strain </b>. FEMS Microbiol Ecol. 65 (2008) 565–573. </p></li>
 +
</div>
-
<p class="texte">Vivamus malesuada, diam vitae cursus posuere, lorem augue ultrices neque, sit amet mattis tellus massa sed enim. Praesent a suscipit tellus, id accumsan arcu. Maecenas vitae volutpat felis. Vivamus felis ligula, vestibulum ut venenatis quis, ultrices in magna. In elementum placerat posuere. Nam viverra risus vitae nunc pulvinar, eu ultrices urna ullamcorper. In elementum dui imperdiet, venenatis neque sed, facilisis augue. Sed maximus vulputate eleifend. Suspendisse at bibendum orci, a porttitor velit. Sed vestibulum magna dui, ut fringilla metus auctor sed.</p>
+
<div class="clear"></div>
-
<p class="texte">Aliquam molestie semper dignissim. In ut lorem dictum, hendrerit mauris ac, sagittis nulla. Phasellus hendrerit tempus ornare. Pellentesque eu justo in dolor viverra suscipit ut posuere augue. Vestibulum ante ipsum primis in faucibus orci luctus et ultrices posuere cubilia Curae; Integer massa orci, pulvinar non blandit in, suscipit nec ex. In pretium lacinia tellus. Duis interdum velit lacinia pellentesque euismod. Nulla pretium accumsan tellus, sed faucibus metus aliquet ac. Donec eleifend dui nec odio volutpat, eu suscipit nibh auctor. Praesent porta ullamcorper risus vitae lobortis. Proin at purus velit. Pellentesque facilisis urna ac nibh mollis, a molestie felis malesuada.</p>
 
     </div>
     </div>

Latest revision as of 03:26, 18 October 2014