Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices

From 2014.igem.org

(Difference between revisions)
(Spreading the Idea of Synthetic Biology)
(Intellectual Property on BioBricks)
 
(28 intermediate revisions not shown)
Line 10: Line 10:
These are only a few of the questions we discussed within our team. To read more about the different aspects of our Policy & Practices work, please click on a panel below:   
These are only a few of the questions we discussed within our team. To read more about the different aspects of our Policy & Practices work, please click on a panel below:   
-
<html>
 
<center>
<center>
-
<ul class="menusmall-grid">
+
<html><ul class="team-grid" style="width:1040px">
-
<!-- Overview -->
+
-
  <li><a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppsocialacceptance" style="color:black">
+
<li style="width:186px;margin-left: 11px;margin-right: 11px;margin-bottom: 11px;margin-top: 11px;">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" ><div class="menukachel">Social Acceptance</div></div>
+
<a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppsocialacceptance" style="color:black">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/3/35/Aachen_14-10-13_Love_Cell_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%">
+
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" style="height: 180px; width: 180px;" > <div class="menukachel" style="top: 32%;line-height: 1.5em;">Social Acceptance</div></div>
 +
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/3/35/Aachen_14-10-13_Love_Cell_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%; height: 180px; width: 180px;">
     </div>
     </div>
     </a>
     </a>
   </li>
   </li>
-
  <li><a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppbiosafety" style="color:black">
+
<li style="width:186px;margin-left: 11px;margin-right: 11px;margin-bottom: 11px;margin-top: 11px;">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" ><div class="menukachel">Biosafety</div></div>
+
<a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppbiosafety" style="color:black">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/1/11/Aachen_14-10-13_Pathogen_Cell_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%">
+
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" style="height: 180px; width: 180px;" > <div class="menukachel" style="top: 40%;line-height: 1.5em;">Biosafety</div></div>
 +
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/1/11/Aachen_14-10-13_Pathogen_Cell_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%; height: 180px; width: 180px;">
     </div>
     </div>
     </a>
     </a>
   </li>
   </li>
-
  <li><a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppeconomics" style="color:black">
+
<li style="width:186px;margin-left: 11px;margin-right: 11px;margin-bottom: 11px;margin-top: 11px;">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" ><div class="menukachel">Economical Standpoint</div></div>
+
<a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppeconomics" style="color:black">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/b/bd/Aachen_14-10-13_Money_Cell_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%">
+
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" style="height: 180px; width: 180px;" > <div class="menukachel" style="top: 32%;line-height: 1.5em;">Economical View</div></div>
 +
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/b/bd/Aachen_14-10-13_Money_Cell_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%; height: 180px; width: 180px;">
     </div>
     </div>
     </a>
     </a>
   </li>
   </li>
-
  <li><a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppbbaip" style="color:black">
+
<li style="width:186px;margin-left: 11px;margin-right: 11px;margin-bottom: 11px;margin-top: 11px;">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" ><div class="menukachel">Intellectual Property on BioBricks</div></div>
+
<a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppbbaip" style="color:black">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/9/9b/Aachen_14-10-14_IP_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%">
+
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" style="height: 180px; width: 180px;"> <div class="menukachel" style="top: 23%;line-height: 1.5em;">Intellectual Property on BioBricks</div></div>
 +
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/9/9b/Aachen_14-10-14_IP_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%; height: 180px; width: 180px;">
     </div>
     </div>
     </a>
     </a>
   </li>
   </li>
-
  <li><a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppblog" style="color:black">
+
<li style="width:186px;margin-left: 11px;margin-right: 11px;margin-bottom: 11px;margin-top: 11px;">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" ><div class="menukachel">Blog</div></div>
+
<a class="menulink" href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices#ppblog" style="color:black">
-
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/b/b8/Aachen_14-10-13_Blogger_Cell_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%">
+
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-info" style="height: 180px; width: 180px;"> <div class="menukachel" style="top: 40%;line-height: 1.5em;">Blog</div></div>
 +
     <div class="menusmall-item menusmall-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/b/b8/Aachen_14-10-13_Blogger_Cell_iNB.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%; height: 180px; width: 180px;">
     </div>
     </div>
     </a>
     </a>
Line 61: Line 64:
<span class="anchor" id="ppsocialacceptance"></span>
<span class="anchor" id="ppsocialacceptance"></span>
-
How can we convince people that the technology we develop is safe to use and that the problems we tackle with our project concern everybody? Unfortunately, a lot people around the world are scared of genetically modified organisms and any application related to them. Though we believe that '''natural skepticism''' towards new and unproved technologies is not just good but especially desirable, the current fear some people encounter gene technology with is a bit disproportionate and might be counterproductive to technological and scientific advance in related fields.
+
How can we convince people that the technology we develop is safe to use and that the problems we tackle with our project concern everybody? Unfortunately, lots of people around the world are scared of genetically modified organisms and any application related to them. Though we believe that '''natural skepticism''' towards new and unproved technologies is not just good but especially desirable, the current fear some people encounter gene technology with is a bit disproportionate and might be counterproductive to technological and scientific advance in related fields.
However, as reported, for example, in an [http://www.rundschau-online.de/magazin/gentechnik--risiko-oder-chance-,15184902,15929266.html article] published in a major local newspaper's magazine, Kölner Stadtanzeiger, the social acceptance of biotechnological products could be higher if people felt informed better and understood the underlying science. Following up on this, we thought about how we can inform people '''factually but in a comprehensible way''' about gene technology and synthetic biology. Before we talk about fancy devices in synthetic biology, how can we '''get down to the underlying issue''' of social rejection of gene technology in general?  
However, as reported, for example, in an [http://www.rundschau-online.de/magazin/gentechnik--risiko-oder-chance-,15184902,15929266.html article] published in a major local newspaper's magazine, Kölner Stadtanzeiger, the social acceptance of biotechnological products could be higher if people felt informed better and understood the underlying science. Following up on this, we thought about how we can inform people '''factually but in a comprehensible way''' about gene technology and synthetic biology. Before we talk about fancy devices in synthetic biology, how can we '''get down to the underlying issue''' of social rejection of gene technology in general?  
Line 68: Line 71:
Combining these two thoughts, we visited '''two schools''', the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium] in Aachen and the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/Neanderlab NEAnderLab] in Hilden, where we talked to students about synthetic biology and the iGEM competition, but also explained the scientific background and social aspects of our project. A delegation of our team also visited the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/MakerFaire MakerFaire] in Hannover, a family-friendly '''exhibition for tinkerers''' of all kinds, to spread the idea of synthetic biology and to discuss our project with the public. When we organized the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Meetup Aachen iGEM Meetup 2014], we also made sure to include a '''public part''' where all teams who participated in our meetup had the opportunity to present their project to a general audience.
Combining these two thoughts, we visited '''two schools''', the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium] in Aachen and the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/Neanderlab NEAnderLab] in Hilden, where we talked to students about synthetic biology and the iGEM competition, but also explained the scientific background and social aspects of our project. A delegation of our team also visited the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/MakerFaire MakerFaire] in Hannover, a family-friendly '''exhibition for tinkerers''' of all kinds, to spread the idea of synthetic biology and to discuss our project with the public. When we organized the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Meetup Aachen iGEM Meetup 2014], we also made sure to include a '''public part''' where all teams who participated in our meetup had the opportunity to present their project to a general audience.
 +
 +
In general, we received '''positive feeback throughout'''. The students we worked with in the NEAnderLab also filled out evaluation sheets, giving us [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/Neanderlab#neanderlabevaluation very good marks] for our collaboration. Through our work with the different people we encountered during our Policy & Practices work, we were able to inform people in a comprehensible way about synthetic biology and gene technology in general. We see this as a ''' successful first step towards a society that embraces the possibilities provided by Synthetic Biology''', and recommend approaches like the school collaborations to other iGEM teams who want the spread the idea of synthetic biology.
To read more about our different public projects, please click on the respective logo below.
To read more about our different public projects, please click on the respective logo below.
-
<html><ul class="team-grid" style="width:1018px">
+
<html><ul class="team-grid" style="width:1064px;">
-
<!-- Overview -->
+
-
  <li><a href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium" style="color:black">
+
<li style="width:220px;margin-left: 23px;margin-right: 23px;margin-bottom: 23px;margin-top: 23px;">
-
     <div class="team-item team-info" >
+
<a href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium" style="color:black">
 +
     <div class="team-item team-info" style="width:214px;height:214px;" >
       <br/><br/>
       <br/><br/>
       <b> Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium</b>
       <b> Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium</b>
Line 83: Line 88:
       <!-- click for more information -->
       <!-- click for more information -->
     </div>
     </div>
-
     <div class="team-item team-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/f/f7/Aachen_14-10-10_Logo_Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%"> </div></a>
+
     <div class="team-item team-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/f/f7/Aachen_14-10-10_Logo_Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%;width:214px;height:214px;"> </div></a>
   </li>
   </li>
-
  <li><a href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/Neanderlab" style="color:black">
+
<li style="width:220px;margin-left: 23px;margin-right: 23px;margin-bottom: 23px;margin-top: 23px;">
-
     <div class="team-item team-info" >
+
<a href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/Neanderlab" style="color:black">
 +
     <div class="team-item team-info" style="width:214px;height:214px;">
       <br/><br/>
       <br/><br/>
       <b> NEAnderLab </b>
       <b> NEAnderLab </b>
Line 95: Line 101:
       <!-- click for more information -->
       <!-- click for more information -->
     </div>
     </div>
-
     <div class="team-item team-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/d/d8/Aachen_14-10-10_Logo_NEAnderLab.jpg); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%"> </div></a>
+
     <div class="team-item team-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/d/d8/Aachen_14-10-10_Logo_NEAnderLab.jpg); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%;width:214px;height:214px;"> </div></a>
   </li>
   </li>
-
  <li><a href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/MakerFaire" style="color:black">
+
<li style="width:220px;margin-left: 23px;margin-right: 23px;margin-bottom: 23px;margin-top: 23px;">
-
     <div class="team-item team-info" >
+
<a href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Collaborations/MakerFaire" style="color:black">
 +
     <div class="team-item team-info" style="width:214px;height:214px;">
       <br/><br/>
       <br/><br/>
       <b> MakerFaire </b>
       <b> MakerFaire </b>
Line 107: Line 114:
       <!-- click for more information -->
       <!-- click for more information -->
     </div>
     </div>
-
     <div class="team-item team-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/5/53/Aachen_14-10-10_Logo_MakerFaire.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%"> </div></a>
+
     <div class="team-item team-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/5/53/Aachen_14-10-10_Logo_MakerFaire.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%;width:214px;height:214px;"> </div></a>
   </li>
   </li>
-
  <li><a href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Meetup" style="color:black">
+
<li style="width:220px;margin-left: 23px;margin-right: 23px;margin-bottom: 23px;margin-top: 23px;">
-
     <div class="team-item team-info" >
+
<a href="https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Meetup" style="color:black">
 +
     <div class="team-item team-info" style="width:214px;height:214px;">
       <br/><br/>
       <br/><br/>
       <b>  Aachen iGEM Meetup 2014 </b>
       <b>  Aachen iGEM Meetup 2014 </b>
Line 119: Line 127:
       <!-- click for more information -->
       <!-- click for more information -->
     </div>
     </div>
-
     <div class="team-item team-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/5/5b/Aachen_14-10-10_Meetup_Logo_white_background_iVA.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%"> </div></a>
+
     <div class="team-item team-img" style="background: url(https://static.igem.org/mediawiki/2014/5/5b/Aachen_14-10-10_Meetup_Logo_white_background_iVA.png); norepeat scroll 0% 0% transparent; background-size:100%;width:214px;height:214px;"> </div></a>
   </li>
   </li>
</ul></html>
</ul></html>
-
 
+
</center>
{{Team:Aachen/BlockSeparator}}
{{Team:Aachen/BlockSeparator}}
Line 132: Line 140:
Our iGEM team is committed to reflect all aspects of the entire project, including biosafety. From the beginning on, the team thoroughly discussed safety issues that could potentially arise with the implementation of ''Cellock Holmes''. The results of these discussions fundamentally influenced the design of [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Project/Measurement_Device ''Watson''] and the choice of potential application fields. Read more about our safety considerations on our [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Safety Safety] page.
Our iGEM team is committed to reflect all aspects of the entire project, including biosafety. From the beginning on, the team thoroughly discussed safety issues that could potentially arise with the implementation of ''Cellock Holmes''. The results of these discussions fundamentally influenced the design of [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Project/Measurement_Device ''Watson''] and the choice of potential application fields. Read more about our safety considerations on our [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Safety Safety] page.
 +
{{Team:Aachen/BlockSeparator}}
{{Team:Aachen/BlockSeparator}}
Line 144: Line 153:
'''Make the world a better place - Open access for scientific advance'''
'''Make the world a better place - Open access for scientific advance'''
-
For both [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Project/Measurement_Device ''WatsOn''] and our [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/OD/F_device OD/F Device], we carried out some market research and came up with concepts for the commercialization of each device. In general, our economical strategy is focused on the open source principle. Low cost and the use of easily available parts have heavily influenced the design choices made when developing our devices. You can find more information on our page [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices/Economics Economical view].
+
For both our [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/Project/Measurement_Device ''WatsOn''] and our [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/OD/F_device OD/F Device], we are following an economical strategy focused on the open source principle. Low cost and the use of easily available parts have '''heavily influenced the design choices''' made when developing our devices. You can find more information on our page [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices/Economics Economical View].
-
{{Team:Aachen/Figure|Aachen 13.10.2014 OD F device ipo.png|title= Figure 1|subtitle= Possible application of our OD/F device|width=800px}}
 
{{Team:Aachen/BlockSeparator}}
{{Team:Aachen/BlockSeparator}}
Line 160: Line 168:
For for information on intellectual property on BioBricks, read the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices/BioBrickIntellectualProperty full proposal] the German iGEM teams composed.
For for information on intellectual property on BioBricks, read the [https://2014.igem.org/Team:Aachen/PolicyPractices/BioBrickIntellectualProperty full proposal] the German iGEM teams composed.
 +
{{Team:Aachen/BlockSeparator}}
{{Team:Aachen/BlockSeparator}}

Latest revision as of 03:33, 18 October 2014

Policy & Practices

During the past summer, we not only refined the technical and biological sides of Cellock Holmes but also considered other aspects of our iGEM project such as social acceptance, biosafety and economical relevance. Will society accept the technology we develop? How can we convince skeptics that synthetic biology is safe? Does our product have economical relevance and how can we best market what we built? What is the target group that might benefit from our devices, and can we make our developments available to not only the privileged population but to everybody in the world? At the meetup of the German iGEM teams in Munich earlier this summer, we also prepared a suggestion on how to handle intellectual proporty rights on BioBricks.

These are only a few of the questions we discussed within our team. To read more about the different aspects of our Policy & Practices work, please click on a panel below:

Aachen 14-10-13 Love Cell iNB.png

Spreading the Idea of Synthetic Biology

How can we convince people that the technology we develop is safe to use and that the problems we tackle with our project concern everybody? Unfortunately, lots of people around the world are scared of genetically modified organisms and any application related to them. Though we believe that natural skepticism towards new and unproved technologies is not just good but especially desirable, the current fear some people encounter gene technology with is a bit disproportionate and might be counterproductive to technological and scientific advance in related fields.

However, as reported, for example, in an article published in a major local newspaper's magazine, Kölner Stadtanzeiger, the social acceptance of biotechnological products could be higher if people felt informed better and understood the underlying science. Following up on this, we thought about how we can inform people factually but in a comprehensible way about gene technology and synthetic biology. Before we talk about fancy devices in synthetic biology, how can we get down to the underlying issue of social rejection of gene technology in general?

At the same time, young students interested in science and engineering are the most valuable future source of innovation. One day, they might be the researchers who develop the solutions to the most pressing issues of our world. For that reason, informing this group of people is of utmost importance and was therefore prioritized in our Policy & Practices work.

Combining these two thoughts, we visited two schools, the Kaiser-Karls-Gymnasium in Aachen and the NEAnderLab in Hilden, where we talked to students about synthetic biology and the iGEM competition, but also explained the scientific background and social aspects of our project. A delegation of our team also visited the MakerFaire in Hannover, a family-friendly exhibition for tinkerers of all kinds, to spread the idea of synthetic biology and to discuss our project with the public. When we organized the Aachen iGEM Meetup 2014, we also made sure to include a public part where all teams who participated in our meetup had the opportunity to present their project to a general audience.

In general, we received positive feeback throughout. The students we worked with in the NEAnderLab also filled out evaluation sheets, giving us very good marks for our collaboration. Through our work with the different people we encountered during our Policy & Practices work, we were able to inform people in a comprehensible way about synthetic biology and gene technology in general. We see this as a successful first step towards a society that embraces the possibilities provided by Synthetic Biology, and recommend approaches like the school collaborations to other iGEM teams who want the spread the idea of synthetic biology.

To read more about our different public projects, please click on the respective logo below.

Aachen 14-10-13 Pathogen Cell iNB.png

Biosafety

Our iGEM team is committed to reflect all aspects of the entire project, including biosafety. From the beginning on, the team thoroughly discussed safety issues that could potentially arise with the implementation of Cellock Holmes. The results of these discussions fundamentally influenced the design of Watson and the choice of potential application fields. Read more about our safety considerations on our Safety page.


Aachen 14-10-13 Money Cell iNB.png

Economical View

The economical considerations regarding our project were carried out according to the motto:

Make the world a better place - Open access for scientific advance

For both our WatsOn and our OD/F Device, we are following an economical strategy focused on the open source principle. Low cost and the use of easily available parts have heavily influenced the design choices made when developing our devices. You can find more information on our page Economical View.


Aachen 14-10-14 IP iNB.png

Intellectual Property on BioBricks

During the meetup of the German iGEM teams from 23rd to 25th May also workshops took place in which amongst others we discussed the topic of bioethics. Moral questions were addressed, regarding the value of life and human influence on it, as well as questions dealing with the possible socioeconomic effects of synthetic biology.

Especially the topic of an open source vs. patent controlled field accounted for a large part of the discussion. During the discussion one student brought up the point that the legal status of parts in registry remains unclear, and that there are parts where only upon a closer look it becomes clear that the rights are company–owned. Because the issue of uncertain legal status of parts in the registry persists, the German iGEM teams wrote a proposal on how to deal with intellectual property rights in the Registry of Standard Biological Parts.

For for information on intellectual property on BioBricks, read the full proposal the German iGEM teams composed.


Aachen 14-10-13 Blogger Cell iNB.png

Blog

On our Blog we post entries about recent news concerning our team's work and activities. We also write about general news from the field of synthetic biology, biotechnology and medicine.